domingo, mayo 20, 2018

Please, Mr. Macri

Another problem that has plagued the country off and on over the years is the government's attempts to manage the peso's exchange rate. If the peso's decline can be slowed, as government bureaucrats typically argue, then that will reduce inflation pressures (thus conveniently shifting the blame from money printing to the foreign exchange market). Notably, the Macri administration, which began in late 2015, wisely abandoned the "official" rate and allowed the peso to float freely (this is shown in Chart #2 where the red and blue lines converged). That restored confidence, and the peso slowed its decline for the next year or so even though money printing continued apace, because demand for pesos improved with improved confidence.

Chart #2

But they have reverted to type of late, by selling $5.5 billion of their forex reserves in order to keep the peso from plunging, as seen in Chart #3. Since that didn't work, their only choice was to jack up short-term interest rates in order to bolster demand for the central bank's debt. Higher interest rates can work in the absence of a decline in money printing (note the similarity to the Fed's use of IOER to bolster banks' demand for bank reserves in the presence of an abundance of excess reserves), but that's not a lasting solution nor will it inspire long-term confidence.

Chart #3

In the end, the math is compelling: since mid-2009, the monetary base has expanded ten-fold, and the peso has lost 83% of its value. The culprit is money printing, and it has got to stop. Any other "fixes" will only prove temporary. Short-term interest rates on Lebac are only effective if they offer investors after-tax compensation for the expected depreciation of the peso. With money printing running at 30% and the peso down 30% in the past year, the after-tax coupon on Lebac needs to be well above 30% to avoid further capital outflows. (Thus it's no surprise that with Lebac rates today at 40%, the peso appears to have stabilized.)
Argentine President Mauricio Macri is, like Donald Trump, a successful businessman who has pledged to restore prosperity to his country. Macri has done a lot of good to date, but this recent peso problem is an unfortunate blemish on his record. I'd like to think that he will take the appropriate steps to get things back on track. So far he's made serious inroads on government corruption and red tape, and the economy's fundamentals have improved measurably (in dollar terms, the Argentine stock market is up 33% since Macri took over). It would be a crime if he didn't set a better course for monetary and fiscal policy. Please, Mr. Macri: cut government spending, pledge to honor Argentina's commitments, get rid of unnecessary taxes, and instruct the central bank to reign in the growth of the money supply.

Copiado de Argentina just got a $5 billion lesson in the Laffer Curve.

No hay comentarios.: